Skip to main content

Alexa Shulman Prompt #5


            Jefree Star is a 33 year old entrepreneur and beauty Youtuber who has taken the platform by storm. Starting off as the face of MySpace, Star published his new music and gained a large following. His target audience consisted of punk rock enthusiasts and outcasts who had a desire to consume his raw and raunchy music  (Shamsian, 2019) However, due to various legal issues, he was forced to leave the music industry in 2013. (Shamsian, 2019) Although Star’s Youtube channel was created in 2006, his career did not take off until 2013. (Dixon, 2018). Star quickly gained subscribers as the majority of his MySpace followers switched over to the innovative platform. Unfortunately, his career nearly derailed in 2017 when a controversial video of him making racist remarks resurfaced. (Bryant, 2019)  To counteract the negative publicity, he apologized, stating, "I say some really disgusting...and embarrassing things...Those videos were 12 years ago and I look at them and it just makes me sick to my stomach." (Dixon, 2018) After his public apology, Star continued producing his original content on Youtube, which varies from innovative makeup looks, detailed reviews of makeup products and lengthy videos on his personal life. Specifically, Star represented different parts of his personality in his tattoos. (Dixon, 2018) Overtime, Star began to create a story along his body, expressing his emotions with the absence of dialogue. This form of self expression attracted many tattoo enthusiasts to his channel and united an audience that fully appreciated the art form.
            Star’s main audience ranges from women ages 13-40. Star also attracts viewers that can be categorized as members of the lgbtq+ community, makeup enthusiasts, vegans (his products are 100% vegan) and those with a more liberal mindset. (Dixon, 2018) Star’s makeup products have references to classic movies, including Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (1971), Jawbreaker (1999) which appeal to the older age group (Jeffree Star, 2019). His use of sexual language and innuendos for his products appeals to rule breakers and to those who defy societal constructs.(Dixon, 2018) Additionally, his sexualization of men, women and gender fluid models in his advertisements appeals to a younger, liberal audience. His own openess about his sexuality and androgynous appearance attracts various members of the LGBTQ+ community (Dixon, 2018).




An intriguing part of Jeffree’s reviews are his brutally honest remarks peppered with raunchy humor and 2019 vernacular. His makeup reviews are consistently real, no matter how close he is to a brand. Often beauty gurus are afraid to express their opinions due to a fear of backlash from corporations, which can jeopardize endorsement deals and future income.( Shamsian, 2019)  However, Star defies these constructs, which gives him an edge. Author Christian Lorentzen does not “think that negative reviews, even snarky ones, are toxic”, thus painting reviewers like Jeffree in a positive light (Lorentzen, 2019) Because Star’s reviews are both positive and negative, he builds trust with his audience. This incentivizes more viewers to subscribe to his channel, for they are able to assess if a product is worth purchasing. Currently Jeffree has over 16 million subscribers and is reaching new levels of success everyday (
Through Star’s ever increasing success, he realized the profitability of his platform. While certain Youtubers make their money solely from endorsements or AdSense, Star harnessed the power of his channel to promote his own beauty and makeup brand. Scrolling through his channel, it is clear that the products that he produces fall under the category of being camp.  According to Susan Sontag, camp “is the love of the exaggerated, the "off," of things-being-what-they-are-not.” (Sontag, 1964). This is clear in one of his videos entitled “Jawbreaker 🍭 Palette & Summer 2019 Collection Reveal!” Within this video, Jeffree Star showcases his “biggest pilot to date” (Jeffree Star, 2019) A key component of this collection is the new neon lip ammunition set. From an outsider's perspective, it is clear that the shape of these lipsticks closely resembles a phallus. (Jeffree Star, 2019) Star’s lip ammunitions emphasize the essence of camp as they are lipsticks transformed into a new shape. Additionally, these products go “beyond straight seriousness” by embodying the themes of irony and satire (Sontag, 1964).  It is ironic that the lipsticks are in the shape of traditional symbols of male virility and dominance.

In addition to using humor, Star utilizes various marketing tools to entice viewers to buy his products. He successfully employs “emotional appeal” and consumer differentiation (management study guide editors). By referencing older makeup products from his line, he creates an emotional appeal and enhances viewers’ desire for something new. This is seen in his explanation of how his new shade of “a bone yellow tone white” differs from the white eyeshadow in his older pallets (Jeffree Star, 2019). In addition, he utilizes the concept of consumer differentiation by “classifying, organising, and labelling” these products. (Adorno and Horkheimer, 1944)

Star wants to give you the illusion of choice if you buy both eyeshadow pallets by claiming that the products are different from each other. This video, in particular, is a 27 minute sales pitch of his new launch. It closely resembles a QVC commercial, which suggests that Youtube is a viable marketing tool. Overall, it is clear that Jeffree succeeded in building on his own fame by using himself as a brand.
           



















Bryant, K. (2019, April 3). Beauty YouTuber Jeffree Star, Internet Infamy, and a Multi-Million-Dollar Makeup Heist. Retrieved from https://www.vanityfair.com/style/2019/04/jeffree-star-million-dollar-makeup-heist.

Dixon, C.-M. L. (2018, July 2). What you don't know about Jeffree Star. Retrieved from https://www.thelist.com/124802/dont-know-jeffree-star/.

Horkheimer, M., & Adorno, T. W. (2017). The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception. Karl Marx, 405-424. Doi: 10.4324/9781315251196-23
Lorentzen, C. (2019, March 19). [Criticism] Like This or Die. Retrieved from https://harpers.org/archive/2019/04/like-this-or-die/.

MSG Management  Study  Guide. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.managementstudyguide.com/advertising-techniques.htm.

Notes On "Camp". (n.d.). Retrieved from https://faculty.georgetown.edu/irvinem/theory/Sontag-NotesOnCamp-1964.html.

Shamsian, J. (2019, October 4). Inside YouTuber Jeffree Star's incredible rise from teen MySpace star to a makeup mogul raking in millions. Retrieved from https://www.insider.com/who-is-jeffree-star-cosmetics-youtube-2019-4#star-first-became-famous-on-myspace-2.
















Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Laila Bailey - #FreeDiddy: the Rise of Diddy Jokes and their Dangerous Implications

On the night of September 16, 2024, the arrest of American rapper Sean “Diddy” Combs took place during his stay at a hotel in Manhattan (AP News, 2024). The following day, his indictment was unsealed for the world to see. With rapid speed, news of his arrest became a trending topic across almost every major social media platform. It seemed that articles and videos describing the content of the indictment were inescapable, and people were quickly made aware that Combs was indicted on a plethora of major charges, including, “sex trafficking, forced labor, interstate transportation for purposes of prostitution, drug offenses, kidnapping, arson, bribery and obstruction of justice.” (AP News, 2024). Despite Combs having been in the spotlight of the media for his legal troubles since November 2023, it wasn’t until his arrest that his situation became more widely discussed, and more social media users began reacting. However, the reactions to his arrest weren’t all as expected. The charges th...
2 comments
Read more

Aitalia Sharpe - Victoria’s Secret: Newly Woke or Performative Facade

In its prime, Victoria’s Secret was the golden standard: their angels stood lean, tall, and flawless, intentionally setting an insurmountable bar of beauty. In the most recent fashion show on October 15, 2024, they featured a far more diverse repertoire of models than they have historically, but is it just a calculated move to save a brand that is failing in this changing society? Until the mid-2010s, Victoria’s Secret remained at the apex of its retail sector, but with growing external demands for inclusive promotion of female bodies, they soon faced backlash for the unrealistic and harmful conventions they spearheaded. The most recent show did feature plus-sized and trans models, yet the majority of models still exemplified the original Victoria’s Secret image. The few diverse bodies sprinkled throughout allowed the company to curate a false image of “wokeness”, allowing them to appear as rebranded while staying true to their structural norms. Victoria’s Secret attempted to twist the...
2 comments
Read more

Diamy Wang - Sexiness is In the Eye of the Beholder

On Nov. 11, the pop culture and entertainment Twitter account Pop Base asked who should win the title of PEOPLE Magazine’s “Sexiest Man Alive,” which was to be officially announced the next day (PopBase, 2024). Despite the deluge of different replies and pictures of shirtless men, none of them were exactly expecting actor John Krasinski, perhaps best known for his role in The Office from 2005 to 2013.  The reaction was swift, with some saying it was “just lazy” to choose Krasinski, who had not been actively working on a high-profile project or promoting one in the past several years (ceejnsight, 2024). Apparently, the “Sexiest Man Alive” label wasn’t purely based on looks — although Twitter users had something to say about that as well.  “[T]hey could’ve chosen someone better ngl,” Twitter user @buffys wrote kindly under Pop Base’s announcement on Nov. 12.  The real question isn’t whether Glen Powell or Jonathan Bailey should have received the title instead, but rather th...
1 comment
Read more